Rajindran, Sharma, Yadav, Saini, and Lamba: Profile of unnatural deaths in adult females – A retrospective study conducted at a tertiary care hospital in Haryana


Introduction

Unnatural deaths can be caused by unintentional or intentional events. Unintentional events are typically accidental, while intentional ones may be the result of suicide or homicide.1 Regardless of the cause, a post-mortem examination must be conducted to rule out foul play.2 The incidence of unnatural deaths can shed light on the prevailing social and mental health status of the population. Medico-legal post-mortem examinations are vital for analysing these deaths.3

Recent attention has focused on crimes against women, which have been a concern for society since ancient times. These crimes have evolved with changing societal values, but they remain a pressing issue. Women aged 18 to 30 face numerous burdens, including mental, physical, psychological, and social challenges. They typically experience major life transitions, such as marriage, employment, and childbearing, during this period.4

Dowry-related deaths remain common in contemporary Indian society, particularly among lower castes and economically disadvantaged groups.5 As more women enter the workforce and pursue higher education, they face additional risks such as occupational hazards and road traffic accidents. Several factors, including age, occupation, lack of support, and parental pressure, contribute to women's unnatural deaths.

Unfortunately, cases of female victimization are often underreported, and research on the topic is scarce. This study aims to explore the profile of unnatural deaths among adult females in this region. By analysing the cause and manner of death, including suicides, homicides, and accidents, the study tries to understand the gravity of female victimization in this part of the country.

Materials and Methods

The study was conducted in the Department of Forensic Medicine, B.P.S. Government Medical College for Women, Khanpur Kalan, Sonipat. This study is a descriptive retrospective analysis that involved gathering data from post-mortem records of all instances of cases of unnatural deaths brought to the mortuary of B.P.S. Government Medical College for Women, Khanpur Kalan, Sonipat between January 2018 and December 2022.

A standardized proforma created specifically for this purpose was utilized to gather details about each case from the postmortem records and the police papers. Details pertaining to age, marital status, occupation, cause of death and manner of death were gathered from each case.

Inclusion criteria

All the cases of adult females brought to mortuary of BPS Government Medical College for Women, Khanpur Kalan, Sonipat for post-mortem examination above the age of 18 years who died in unnatural circumstances. Age was confirmed by documentary evidences like birth certificate, identification cards, Aadhar card etc.

Exclusion criteria

  1. Cases of age less than 18 years of age.

  2. Cases where death was due to natural cause.

  3. Cases of negative and obscure autopsies

The data collected was then thoroughly analysed to obtain a comparative evaluation.

Results

Of the 1564 autopsies conducted, 204 (13.04%) were of females aged over 18 which were identified as unnatural deaths. The majority of cases (50.1%) belonged to the age group of 18 to 30 years, with the highest number being 43 (21.08%) recorded between the ages of 21 to 25.(Table 1)

152 (75.49%) of the victims were married, while 42 (20.59%) were unmarried, 6 (3.43%) were widowed, and 1 (0.49%) was divorced.(Table 2) The occupation of the deceased showed that most of the cases, 129 (63.24%), were housewives (married and unemployed), followed by 37 (18.14%) working women, 22 (10.78%) students, and 16 (7.84%) unemployed.(Table 3)

Table 1

Showing age-wise distribution of the cases

Age

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

Total

Percent

18-20

6

7

3

8

4

28

13.73

21-25

7

10

7

10

9

43

21.08

26-30

5

12

4

7

5

33

16.18

31-35

9

6

1

5

4

25

12.25

36-40

9

6

7

2

4

28

13.73

41-45

4

3

0

2

3

12

5.88

46-50

4

1

2

5

1

13

6.37

>50

2

6

0

8

6

22

10.78

Total

46

51

24

47

36

204

Table 2

Showing distribution of the cases based on marital status

Marital status

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

Total

Percent

Unmarried

7

14

6

12

3

42

20.59

Married

39

37

18

31

29

154

75.49

Widow

0

0

0

3

4

7

3.43

Divorced

0

0

0

1

0

1

0.49

Table 3

Showing distribution of the cases based on occupation

Occupation

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

Total

Percent

Student

4

4

4

9

1

22

10.78

House wife

31

27

15

30

26

129

63.24

Working

10

14

3

4

6

37

18.14

Unemployed

1

6

2

4

3

16

7.84

Table 4

Showing distribution of the cases based on cause of death

Cause of death

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

Total

Percent

Poisoning

27

31

16

28

22

124

60.78

Asphyxia

3

9

3

7

4

26

12.74

Electrocution

1

0

0

1

3

5

2.45

Envenomation

0

0

0

2

1

3

1.47

Road traffic accident

7

8

3

8

4

30

14.70

Polytrauma

4

0

0

0

0

4

1.96

Firearm

1

0

0

0

1

2

0.98

Drowning

2

2

1

1

1

7

3.43

Railway track accident

0

0

1

0

0

1

0.49

Burns

1

1

0

0

0

2

0.98

Table 5

Showing distribution of the cases based on manner of death

Manner of death

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

Total

Percent

Suicidal

30

38

16

33

25

142

69.60

Homicidal

5

1

4

2

2

14

6.86

Accidental

11

12

4

12

9

48

23.53

Discussion

An increase in unnatural deaths within a society is a clear indication of the absence of social and mental well-being. The situation is especially critical when it comes to women who have fallen prey to long-term deprivation of socio-economic and human rights. Such cases reflect a negative image of the society they belong to. Therefore, studying the profile of unnatural deaths is highly important in formulating preventive strategies and policies.

This present study focuses on the descriptive analysis of unnatural deaths of adult females above the age of 18 who underwent post-mortem examination at a tertiary care centre for a period of five years. Out of the 1564 cases brought for examination, 204 of them (13.04%) were related to unnatural deaths of adult females. It is observed that the majority of cases, which account for 43 cases, were from the age group of 21 to 25 years. This trend is consistent with other studies6, 7, 8, 9 that highlight that the reason for the high incidence of cases during this age group is due to the unpreparedness of young females in dealing with married life's stress.

In this study, 75.49% of the unnatural female deaths were of married women, and the maximum deaths were observed to be within the early years of marriage. This finding is consistent with other studies6, 7, 10 where dowry-related deaths have become a norm within the initial years of marriage. The present study also highlights that housewives constitute the maximum bulk of unnatural deaths in females. Other studies6, 7, 8, 9 also showed housewives to be prime victims, showing that economically dependent women are more susceptible to domestic violence.

The manner of death has been identified as a critical aspect of unnatural deaths, and in most cases, it is suicidal, accounting for 142 cases (69.60%).(Table 5) The use of poison has been identified as the single most common method, accounting for 60.78% of all unnatural female deaths in this study. This is primarily due to the easy availability, low cost, and efficacy of poison. Hanging was identified as the second most common method of suicide. Road traffic accidents were found to be the most contributory factor to accidental deaths, accounting for 62.5%, followed by drowning (14.58%), electrocution (10.42%), and envenomation (6.25%). In cases of homicidal deaths, ligature strangulation was found to be the most common method, accounting for 42.8%, followed by assault causing morbid injuries (28.58%) and firearm injuries (7%).(Table 4) These findings are consistent with other studies.4, 5 Other studies11, 12 found hanging to be the most common suicidal method. However, studies by Kumar TM et al. (2006),13 Kumar S et al (2013),14 Arora S (2016)15 and Kitulwatte IDG et al. (2017)16 show contrasting results where accidents were reported as the most common manner of death.

Conclusion

This study sheds light on the various causes of female deaths and highlights the need for measures to tackle socio-economic and human rights deprivation, domestic violence, and mental health issues that contribute to these deaths. Policies must be implemented to address the high incidence of marital and dowry-related deaths in the early years of marriage, while measures promoting female economic independence can help reduce domestic violence. Despite some positive changes brought about by modernization, such as increased education and employment opportunities for women, the problem of unnatural deaths, particularly those related to crimes against women, continues to be a pressing concern in India. Research must be carried out to better understand the root causes of this problem and to develop effective prevention and support strategies.

Sources of Funding

Nil.

Conflict of Interest

Nil.

References

1 

T Meera P Nandeibam L Fimate SK Maring M Sangma Spectrum of unnatural female deaths in Manipur: a postmortem studyJ Med Soc20152928891

2 

KSN Reddy Essentials of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology35th EdJaypee Brothers Medical PublishersNew Delhi2022142

3 

S Chourasia S Dhaka R Rautji KV Radhakrishna Epidemiological Profile of In-Hospital Deaths in a Tertiary Health Care Centre: A 3-Year Retrospective Study in Western MaharashtraJ Med Acad20203239

4 

PM Narayankar SR Jagannatha An autopsy study of pattern of unnatural deaths among youth conducted at a tertiary care teaching hospital in South IndiaJ Indian Acad Forensic Med20234513640

5 

PB Parmar GB Rathod P Bansal AM Maru B Pandya AK Bansal Pattern of suspicious deaths of married females brought for medico-legal autopsy at teaching institute of IndiaJ Family Med Prim Care202312921103

6 

M Sane A Karibasavaiah Unnatural deaths of adult females in South Bangalore: an autopsy studyJ Ind Acad Forensic Med20143621302

7 

BK Guntheti UP Singh A study of unnatural female deaths was reported to a tertiary care hospital in Khammam TelanganaJ Ind Acad Forensic Med20163844604

8 

MB Parchake RV Kachare SA Khade G Tasgaonkar R Sukhadeve S Giri Study of Unnatural Female Deaths in Southern Marathwada Region of IndiaSch J App Med Sci201532D78996

9 

KU Zine A Magadlimath SJ Gadge VS Kalokhe RG Bhusale Study of some socio etiological aspects of unnatural female deaths at government medical college, AurangabadJ Ind Acad Forensic Med20093132107

10 

RC Dere KM Rajoo Study of unnatural deaths in females a medicolegal study at rural medical college LoniJ Indian Acad Forensic Med20113332113

11 

BL Zohlupuii JD Sungoh T Meera Pattern of female deaths in Manipur: an autopsy based cross sectional studyIndian J Forensic Community Med2020741836

12 

PL Sujatha BS Shankar BC Shivakumar S Shaji Profile of unnatural deaths in adult females in Bangalore northJ Indian Acad Forensic Med2022441403

13 

PK Agarwal Study of Unnatural Deaths in Females in Garhwal Region of UttrakhandMedico-Legal Update2017172221

14 

S Kumar AK Verma W Ali A Pandey I Ahmad US Singh A study of unnatural female death profile in Lucknow, IndiaAm J Forensic Med Pathol20133443526

15 

S Arora Profile of unnatural female deaths in Jammu region-an autopsy based studyIndian J Forensic Med Toxicol201610259

16 

IDG Kitulwatte PAS Edirisinghe P Mendis PR Wijesinghe A Fernando R Abeyrathna Study on the pattern of unnatural deaths of women brought for medico-legal autopsySrilanka J Forensic Med Sci Law2017811322



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article History

Received : 02-03-2024

Accepted : 22-05-2024


View Article

PDF File   Full Text Article


Downlaod

PDF File   XML File   ePub File


Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

Article DOI

https://doi.org/10.18231/j.ijfcm.2024.014


Article Metrics






Article Access statistics

Viewed: 485

PDF Downloaded: 148



Medical Abbreviation List